| Platinum | Cucina Tagliani |
| Gold | Peoria Artisan Brewery |
| Silver | Uncle Sam's |
| Bronze | Greek Wraps |
| Top Pick | Bourbon and Bones |
| Top Pick | Cousin Vinny Pizza and Pasta |
| Top Pick | Grimaldi's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mercer's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | V's Taproom |
| Top Pick | Village Inn |