| Platinum | Mercer's Restaurant |
| Gold | Peoria Cafe |
| Silver | Uncle Sam's |
| Bronze | That Place Subs and Salads |
| Top Pick | Bigs |
| Top Pick | Brothers Family Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Cracker Barrel Old Country Store |
| Top Pick | Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana |
| Top Pick | Haymaker |
| Top Pick | The Moon Saloon |